Wood Fired Pizza

All of our pizzas are cooked in our 900 degree wood fired oven. We use only fresh mozzarella only, you will not find processed cheese here. (Sorry string cheese lovers)

Wood Fired Specialties

More than pizza, to say the least. Coney Island Pizza makes fresh wood fired meatballs. All of the food is made with the labor of love.

Wine and Desserts

Coney Island Pizza serves as a premier outlet for the locally produced Ventimiglia Vineyard Wine from Wantage, NJ Sangria is also offered seasonally and the staple Blood Orange Sangria is offered year round.

All Desserts are made on premise. The seasonal cannolis are a big seller during the holidays specializing in Peppermint Patty Cannolis and Pumpkin Cannolis.